Report on the June 16 meeting

We played:

Schedule

We’ll be meeting as a dropin group for the next few weeks, at
7:45 PM every Tuesday, at my place.

We probably won’t meet on Tuesday, August 11, so that we can go
play with Francis Rhodes and the West Gallery Quire.

Party

Remember that we’re having a party on this Sunday, June 21,
starting at 4 PM. Invitations are
here; invite anyone you think would enjoy it.

If the weather is decent, we’ll be out in the back yard with
the grill going, so if you want to bring something to grill, feel
free, or bring a side dish or dessert.

New Site

I’m making a fair amount of progress on the new site design.
If you’ve been going to laymusic.org to download music,
you should now be going to serpentpublications.org
for that. Please change any bookmarks or links.

laymusic.org will
continue to be the site for groups such as this one and The West Gallery Quire,
and for my
blog.

AOL users

If you get your email from AOL, you probably haven’t been
getting these emails for a while. Please read my blog entry
about why not to use AOL for an explanation of why this happened,
and what I did to get it to stop. If you have another address, I
recommend that you use it for this list. If the emails stop, and
you want to read them, most of what’s in the emails is also posted
in the blog.

Farm Share has started

One of the exciting things that happened last week that didn’t
have anything to do with Early Music was that my farm share
started delivering.

Of course, I had less time for cooking and spent more time
eating out than usual last week, so I haven’t done much with it except eat
a lot of salads for lunch. But the band is coming over tonight,
and I have dinner with friends on Thursday and the party on Sunday, so I’m sure I’ll start getting rid
of all those bags in the refrigerator faster than I have been.

Here’s some of the email they sent me last week before I picked
up the share:

Spinach, one pound. We’ve had a warm spring, and this first spinach is big! The flavor is outstanding, and you can eat it stem and all. The spinach, like just about all of our produce, is washed once by us. You will likely want to wash it again, to remove that last of our fine sandy loam topsoil from the leaves.

Salad mix, 1/2 pound. Our mesclun is a mix of lettuces, tat soi, mizuna, baby red kale, and a handful of other mild greens. We washed it twice, but it will want another washing. The key to keeping the mesclun and other greens fresh all week is to store the greens dry. You can pat them dry with a towel, or, better yet, wash and spin them dry with a salad spinner, then store in a sealed plastic bag or plastic container.

Lettuce, 2 heads. We grow a dozen or so head lettuce varieties over the course of the season. The butterheads are especially delicious this time of year (my 10 year old niece, a picky eater, had 3 helpings of “really good” salad last night). We’ve included one butterhead and one leaf lettuce today.

Radishes A crunchy addition to salads, we grow these only in spring. Their grand size is evidence of the warm spring. I just found a recipe for Sauteed Radishes with Radish Greens or Arugula in the Farmer John’s Cookbook. Basically, sautee quartered radishes and the greens in butter, lemon, salt and pepper. Sounds interesting…

Bok Choy Also known as Pak Choi, this Asian cooking green is lovely sautéed, in stir-fries and soups. Store it loosely wrapped in a plsatic bag in the fridge, so the outer leaves don’t wilt. To prepare, pull or cut the stalks away from the base. Cut the stalks in crescents like celery. The leaves will only need brief cooking time, so add them at the very end. See the recipe below.

Arugula This green is slightly peppery, and very tender today. We grow it under row covers, to protect the leaves from nibbling beetles. Try in salads or on sandwiches. The snappy taste will mellow if you slightly wilt the arugula.

Salad Turnips These “Hakurai” turnips are like a sweet radish, and are delicious raw in salads, grated or chopped. We also like them sauteed with greens. Unlike the more traditonal fall turnip, these Hakurai are too watery for roasts or stews – I find they get mushy.

Coming Soon: Strawberries.

I had Hakurai turnips in the farm share last fall, and I didn’t
think of eating them raw, so I braised them in white wine, and it
was good, but I’ll probably try them in a salad this time.

This is making me hungry, so I’m going to go cream the spinach
and have it on toast.

The last I heard, there were still a few shares left, so if you
live in this part of the world (Boston area or Winchester, New Hampshire) and this sounds interesting, go to
the Picadilly Farm
site
and sign up.

Friday at the Boston Early Music Festival

Stile Antico

In general, I spend a lot of my life fighting the idea that you
have to have started studying choral music at the age of 5 and
have the ideal voice and be able to sing perfectly in tune with no
instrumental support to sing the vocal polyphony of the sixteenth
century. This is true in the sense that you don’t have to make
tennis your life to enjoy getting exercise that way, but probably
nobody will enjoy watching you the way they’ll enjoy Roger
Federer.

The members of Stile Antico all started studying choral music
at early ages, and they have impeccable intonation and gorgeous
voices. And the audience really enjoyed their program of 16th
century music to texts from the Song of Songs.

There’s a tradeoff in singing polyphonic music — you can blend
all the voices into a beautiful sound, or you can make the voices
all sound different so the audience can hear the individual
lines. I believe this group probably performs this balance as
well as can be expected, but Emmanuel Church isn’t the right place
to err even a little bit on the side of the beautiful sound, and
there were places where I couldn’t follow the inner lines. But
when I could, I thought they were singing very “horizontally” for
a group that size.

Another problem with Emmanuel Church is that while it’s a
beautiful live space for some kinds of music, it isn’t at all kind
to musicians who want to provide verbal discussion of what they’re
doing. So I can’t tell you whether the remarks from the sanctuary
were incisive and illuminating, because I really couldn’t hear
them well enough. Based on the program notes, they may have still
been arguing with some straw man who thinks the author of the
Song of Songs wasn’t thinking about sex. But maybe
the straw man is real flesh somewhere, or they were saying
something subtler than that that I missed.

And while we’re complaining about Emmanuel Church, the
temperature outside was a balmy 70-something (Fahrenheit), and
inside it was in the 90’s. This made it even harder to
concentrate well enough to follow the inner lines.

Micrologus

The people who play Medieval music in concerts will be the
first to tell you that they are doing a lot of “reconstruction” in
order to play pieces that have parts and rhythms. We have
fragmentary notations for the tunes and sometimes a bit of an idea
for a harmony part, but usually they’re completely guessing about
the rhythm, and often completely composing any kind of
harmony.

I haven’t been going to many concerts like this, because I
often find that the composers of modern reconstructions of
Medieval music aren’t as good composers as the 16th 17th and 18th
century composers who wrote the other music played at early music
festivals, and you can’t do everything.

But this was the second performance this year by people who do
this that I’ve really enjoyed. I assumed on Tuesday that I was
enjoying the Judith composition (Dialogos doesn’t even
claim to be “reconstructing” anything actually performed in the
sixteenth century) because it was Renaissance polyphony, which is
my favorite form of music in the whole world. But this
performance of Italian music from the fourteenth century was just
as fascinating.

Since I already complained about Emmanuel Church as a venue for
polyphony and as a space for concentration by the sleep-deprived,
I will only remark here that there was probably some beautiful
harp playing on this concert that I couldn’t hear, in spite of
having a fairly close seat. Someone should tell harp players that you
can’t hear lap harps in a space that seats hundreds of people.

But the singing and the percussion and the wind instruments all
came through very well.

The trumpets were, alas, only playing
rhythmic drones under the bagpipes. I should note that this was
the only brass playing in the entire official Festival
Program. Since there was also very little reed playing on the
the official programs, I would suggest that the organizers either
rethink their priorities, or change the name Boston Early
Music
Festival to Boston Early String and Flute
Festival.

Other remarks

I had intended to also review Tangled Mysteries: Clavichord Music of Renaissance Poland:
Judith Conrad, clavichords
, which I enjoyed very much,
but I have to be getting to the exhibition to pick up my
instruments. The short review is that it’s fascinating music
which should be played oftener, and which the performer
(disclosure: my sister) did a very good job of making accessible
to a fairly diverse audience.

The evening and 11 PM concerts were the first two that had the
kind of attendance I would have expected from earlier
festivals. Emmanuel Church was essentially sold out for
Stile Antico, and most of the seats that were any
good were taken for Micrologus. This probably
happened largely because of the word-of-mouth recommendations
from people who saw their performance earlier in the week, which
I didn’t get to, but which was reviewed
by the Boston Globe.

Status of site rollout

No time for a long post today, and my head is full of lists of
things I have to do by tomorrow morning, so you get some of the
list.

I’m attempting to roll out the SerpentPublications.org
site by the time I start distributing flyers about it at the Boston Early Music Festival. The
exhibition starts tomorrow morning, and I’m planning to be there
with a stack of flyers.

If you aren’t interested in the site, come back later in the
week, when I’ll be mostly posting about all the exciting concerts
I’ve been seeing.

Site Content

All the database-backed stuff is there, with enough PHP and
mysql to provide most of the functionality of the old site, plus
previews where I’ve generated them.

Unfortunately, moving all the relevant written stuff from the
old site to the new site is being more of a pain than I expected.
It needs a lot of editing, and should probably be completely
redone from scratch. This can happen in the next month, but not
today. So I’ll probably just leave some of the old stuff on the
old site, and move and redirect it as I get it rewritten or decide
it’s not relevant any more.

One missing piece of functionality is the list in order by the
date the PDF was last generated. I don’t believe this is getting
used much, but it’s certainly useful to me when I write the blog
posts, so I may end up putting something like it back.

I haven’t yet written the PHP for the search form, or added the
number of parts to the database.

But I did get the code for generating previews, and a script
for automatically uploading the files when they’ve been rebuilt.
So working on the site is going to be a lot easier, and
updates should happen in much closer to real time than they have
been.

I’m also hoping that the previews will make the site a lot
easier to use even without the search functionality and the part
counting in the database.

Appearance

Page design

The pages don’t look like I’d planned them yet. Doing major
image editing while I’m also doing major programming in two
languages I don’t know very well just didn’t turn out to be
possible. I’ll take a Friday afternoon art session some day soon
and beat the images and the wordpress PHP into submission.

The plan is to have an image at the top and bottom of the page,
where the facsimile of “Adieu mes amours” from Petrucci’s
Odhecaton merges into the lilypond transcription I’ve
done. (See this
post
, and this
later one
for the material I have to work with.)

I haven’t either gotten the images of the merge, or convinced
wordpress to put images where I want them yet.

Color scheme

One comment I got from one of the friends I asked to look at the site
was that it was pink on white, which isn’t the color scheme scheme
she would have picked. This is actually not true of the site as a
whole, but the page I asked people to look at particularly, the Music
by
composers
page, is all links, and the links are
currently fuchsia. So I might change that to a darker pink, that
would still go with the teal body text and headers.

Navigation and sidebar

I think the current theme with the page hierarchy as drop-down
menus along the top is a clear improvement over the old two (for
the blog) or three (for the static site) column layout. And when
I get all the pages written, it will be more obviously useful.

The sidebar looks a little cluttered. When I have time to work
on it, I’ll get the links a bit better organized.

Also, when there’s a bit more data, I’ll put in some links to
the most frequently downloaded pieces and blog entries.

I wrote the framework for counting how often a file has been
downloaded and putting it in the database in a fairly short amount
of time yesterday afternoon. This made me feel good about having
recovered my programming skills.

Interface

As I said, I haven’t written the grand search form for
searching by country and century and number or parts. But I think
people will find that the
bycomposer page is easier to use than it used to be, and if all
you want is to search on title or composer, “find in page” there
will do it.

Another thing that has to happen today is linking from the top
level to the wordpress site. I haven’t decided whether to just do
a redirect or to have a splash page.

I did a laymusic.org splash page once in the Gimp that I felt
pretty good about, but it can’t be used directly as is. But you
should look at it anyway:

[proposed splash page for laymusic.org]

Unfortunately, it won’t be usable for the laymusic.org redesign
either, since I’ve split the music off to the new site.

Another concern is that the view I defined on the database is
pretty slow. I set up some more indexes, and cut a couple of
seconds off the search, but it really takes about 10 seconds to
get anything out of the database if you go through that view. I
may have to work on that some more later.

Summary

So as of tomorrow, there will still be rough edges, but I feel
pretty good about what I’ve done.

I did pretty minimal changes to the brochure from two years
ago, so that wasn’t an enormous amount of work. I posted it on
the serpentpublications
blog.

Revolutionary Road, the movie

I posted about
the book
a few weeks ago, and said I wasn’t going to bother
with the movie, but I watched it last night anyway.

It was actually better than I expected. Kate Winslett is
pretty good, although I still kept seeing January Jones from Mad
Men instead. As I expected, Leonardo DaCaprio’s matinée
idol good looks aren’t really right for Frank. And of course,
they don’t have anything like as much good detail in a 2-hour
movie as in a 300 page book.

For instance, the first scene in the book, which really grabs
the reader, goes into a great amount of detail about why the
production of Bus Stop that April stars in is such
a flop in spite of all the hard work that a lot of people did.
The movie skips all that and goes straight to the audience
reaction.

Another scene that’s especially good in the book and left out
of the movie was when April cleans all the dirtiest parts of the
house before botching the abortion.

I wasn’t especially impressed with the costumes and scenery,
but the sound track was definitely an addition.

Michael Shannon,
who plays the mentally ill son of the real estate lady was
especially good in a fairly difficult role.

So on the whole, read the book or watch Mad Men if
you really want period melodrama, but if you’ve done that and
still want some more, it’s not a terrible movie.

http://rcm.amazon.com/e/cm?t=laymusicorg-20&o=1&p=8&l=as1&asins=0307454622&fc1=000000&IS2=1&lt1=_blank&m=amazon&lc1=0000FF&bc1=000000&bg1=FFFFFF&f=ifr
http://rcm.amazon.com/e/cm?t=laymusicorg-20&o=1&p=8&l=as1&asins=B0016Q2D66&fc1=000000&IS2=1&lt1=_blank&m=amazon&lc1=0000FF&bc1=000000&bg1=FFFFFF&f=ifr

http://rcm.amazon.com/e/cm?t=laymusicorg-20&o=1&p=8&l=as1&asins=B000YABIQ6&fc1=000000&IS2=1&lt1=_blank&m=amazon&lc1=0000FF&bc1=000000&bg1=FFFFFF&f=ifr
http://rcm.amazon.com/e/cm?t=laymusicorg-20&o=1&p=8&l=as1&asins=B001GCUER0&fc1=000000&IS2=1&lt1=_blank&m=amazon&lc1=0000FF&bc1=000000&bg1=FFFFFF&f=ifr

Sonia Sotomayor

I’ve been reading the discussion of Sonia Sotomayor’s
nomination to be a justice of the Supreme court with more interest
than I sometimes read such things. She’s roughly my age, and it
still surprises me when people who seem that much like me get be
judges and presidents.

I thought I’d point you at two of the more interesting articles
I’ve run into.

Slate Magazine has an article called The Invitation You Can’t Refuse —
Why Sonia Sotomayor was talking about race in the first place.

It’s written by a latina lawyer, who makes the point:

Imagine Chief Justice John Roberts being invited by members of his own cultural network to deliver remarks for the Honorable William H. Rehnquist Law & Cultural Diversity Memorial Lecture on what special qualities white men bring to the bench: “What makes your approach, as a white male, different from that of your black judicial colleagues?” “Does being a white man give you special insight into the perspective of white male defendants in discrimination cases?” “Has the presence of white men on the bench made any difference in American law?” Odds are he wouldn’t last two minutes before treading on someone’s sensibilities. But this political high-wire act is expected from minority figures as a matter of course.

This morning’s New York Times has an article comparing the
biographies of Sotomayor and Clarence Thomas called For
Sotomayor and Thomas, Paths Diverge at Race
.

Among the striking paralels drawn between these lives are that
when they arrived in college, both felt that they didn’t speak
English as well as they wanted to:

Ms. Sotomayor had grown up in the Bronx speaking Spanish; Mr. Thomas’s relatives in Pin Point, Ga., mixed English with Gullah, a language of the coastal South. Both attended Catholic school, where they were drilled by nuns in grammar and other subjects. But at college, they realized they still sounded unpolished.

Ms. Sotomayor shut herself in her dorm room and eventually resorted to grade-school grammar textbooks to relearn her syntax. Mr. Thomas barely spoke, he said later, and majored in English literature to conquer the language.

“I just worked at it,” he said in an interview years later, “on my
pronunciations, sounding out words.”

Another similarity was what happened when they were interviewed
for jobs after graduation from law school:

Mr. Thomas and Ms. Sotomayor did have one experience in common: law firm interviewers asked them if they really deserved their slots at Yale, implying that they might not have been accepted if they were white.

Ms. Sotomayor fought back so intensely — against a Washington firm, now merged with another — that she surprised even some of the school’s Hispanics. She filed a complaint with a faculty-student panel, which rejected the firm’s initial letter of apology and asked for a stronger one. Minority and women’s groups covered campus with fliers supporting her. Ms. Sotomayor eventually dropped her complaint, but the firm had already suffered a blow to its reputation.

Mr. Thomas was more private about the experience — even some friends do not recall it — but he took it hard. With rejection letters piling up, he feared he would not be able to support his wife and young son.

The problem, Mr. Thomas concluded, was affirmative action. Whites would not hire him, he concluded, because no one believed he had attended Yale on his own merits. He felt acute betrayal: his education was supposed to put him on equal footing, but he was not offered the jobs that his white classmates were getting. He saved the pile of rejection letters, he said in a speech years later.

“It was futile for me to suppose that I could escape the stigmatizing
effects of racial preference,” he wrote in his autobiography.

I certainly hope they get the confirmation process over in time
so that it doesn’t interfere with fixing health care and the
economy, but meanwhile, it’s producing some interesting writing.

West Gallery Quire Concert

I played serpent with the West Gallery Quire last
night, in a concert at the Brighton-Allston Congregational
Church.

It was a very pleasant audience, and the group really enjoyed
playing for them and eating together afterwards.

I don’t have any pictures, and I don’t think anyone wants me to
let you hear the rehearsal recordings. But I’m feeling pretty
good about the serpent playing.

To begin with, the church is a really good room for the serpent
to play in. And the tuba playing I’ve been doing the last couple
of weeks to get ready for the Wakefield Summer Band has gotten my
low range much more reliable than it sometimes is.

I think historically, there would have usually been at most one
instrument per part, and the usual kind of church choir
distribution, modified by some of the social dynamics described in
the quote below. And the instruments would have been fairly loud
instruments that could be depended on by the singers.

This group tends to be about half instruments, some of whom are
playing for their personal pleasure, and can maybe be heard by the
person next to them, but not by anyone else. Last night, we
really could have used another soprano. The serpent was loud
enough that having only two bass singers wasn’t a balance problem,
but it’s more fun when the serpent can blend into a section.

Another issue with this group is that the director doesn’t
really ever read the words of the hymns, so he’s always deciding
what verses to sing on some pretty arbitrary criteria. Last night
we sang the 23rd Psalm in the Old Version of Sternhold and
Hopkins. (I’d give you a link, but the site I found seems to be
down.) It has 5 verses, and we sang 4 of them. Several of us
lobbied for doing all 5, since it’s a well-known text, and it
seems to be left hanging if you end on verse 4. But the director
had decided that 4 verses was the right number, and it didn’t even
occur to him that he should read all 5 and decide on the basis of
the poetry which was the right one to leave out.

Literary reference

Since we’re talking about West Gallery Music, I found a
literary reference a couple of years ago that I think describes
the milieu and its destruction better and more succinctly than the
Thomas Hardy Under the Greenwood Tree chapters that
are always cited. Thomas Hardy is certainly a better writer than
Thomas Hughes, but I think this excerpt should be available on the
web for people who want to read about West Gallery Music.

It’s from Tom Brown at Oxford by Thomas Hughes, which you can now get
in a number of formats from manybooks.net.

This is from CHAPTER XVIII

ENGLEBOURNE VILLAGE

The figure of fun was a middle-aged man of small stature, and very
bandy-legged, dressed in a blue coat and brass buttons, and carrying a
great bass-viol bigger than himself, in a rough baize cover. He came out
of a footpath into the road just before them, and, on seeing them,
touched his hat to Miss Winter, and then fidgeted along with his load,
and jerked his head in a deprecatory manner away from them as he walked
on, with the sort of look and action which a favorite terrier uses when
his master holds out a lighted cigar to his nose. He was the village
tailor and constable, also the principal performer in the church-music
which obtained in Englebourn. In the latter capacity he had of late come
into collision with Miss Winter.

For this was another of the questions which divided the parish–The
great church music question. From time immemorial, at least ever since
the gallery at the west end had been built, the village psalmody had
been in the hands of the occupiers of that Protestant structure. In the
middle of the front row sat the musicians, three in number, who played
respectively a bass-viol, a fiddle, and a clarionet. On one side of them
were two or three young women, who sang treble–shrill, ear-piercing
treble–with a strong nasal Berkshire drawl in it. On the other side of
the musicians sat the blacksmith, the wheelwright, and other tradesmen
of the place. Tradesmen means in that part of the country what we mean
by artisan, and these were naturally allied with the laborers, and
consorted with them. So far as church-going was concerned, they formed a
sort of independent opposition, sitting in the gallery, instead of in
the nave, where the farmers and the two or three principal
shopkeepers–the great landed and commercial interests–regularly sat
and slept, and where the two publicans occupied pews, but seldom made
even the pretence of worshipping.

The rest of the gallery was filled by the able-bodied male
peasantry. The old worn-out men generally sat below in the free seats;
the women also, and some few boys. But the hearts of these latter were
in the gallery–a seat on the back benches of which was a sign that they
had indued the toga virilis, and were thenceforth free from maternal and
pastoral tutelage in the matter of church-going. The gallery thus
constituted had gradually usurped the psalmody as their particular and
special portion of the service; they left the clerk and the school
children, aided by such of the aristocracy below as cared to join, to do
the responses; but, when singing time came, they reigned supreme. The
slate on which the Psalms were announced was hung out from before the
centre of the gallery, and the clerk, leaving his place under the
reading-desk, marched up there to give them out. He took this method of
preserving his constitutional connection with the singing, knowing that
otherwise he could not have maintained the rightful position of his
office in this matter. So matters had stood until shortly before the
time of our story.

The present curate, however, backed by Miss Winter, had tried a
reform. He was a quiet man, with a wife and several children, and small
means. He had served in the diocese ever since he had been ordained, in
a hum-drum sort of way, going where he was sent for, and performing his
routine duties reasonably well, but without showing any great aptitude
for his work. He had little interest, and had almost given up expecting
promotion, which he certainly had done nothing particular to merit. But
there was one point on which he was always ready to go out of his way,
and take a little trouble. He was a good musician, and had formed choirs
at all his former curacies.

Soon after his arrival, therefore, he, in concert with Miss Winter, had
begun to train the children in church-music. A small organ, which had
stood in a passage in the Rectory for many years, had been repaired, and
appeared first at the schoolroom, and at length under the gallery of the
church; and it was announced one week to the party in possession, that,
on the next Sunday, the constituted authorities would take the
church-music into their own hands. Then arose a strife, the end of which
had nearly been to send the gallery off, in a body, headed by the
offended bass-viol, to the small red-brick little Bethel at the other
end of the village. Fortunately the curate had too much good sense to
drive matters to extremities, and so alienate the parish constable, and
a large part of his flock, though he had not tact or energy enough to
bring them round to his own views. So a compromise was come to; and the
curate’s choir were allowed to chant the Psalms and Canticles, which had
always been read before, while the gallery remained triumphant masters
of the regular Psalms.

Here the ladies turned in, and were going up the walk towards the school
door, when the constable summoned up courage to speak on the matter
which was troubling him, and, resting the bass-viol carefully on his
right foot, calling out after them,

“Oh, please marm! Miss Winter!”

“Well,” she said quietly, turning round, “what do you wish to say?”

“Why, please mann, I hopes as you don’t think I be any ways unked ’bout
this here quire singin’, as they calls it I’m sartin you knows as there
ain’t amost nothing I wouldn’t do to please ee.”

“Well, you know how to do it very easily,” she said when he paused. “I
don’t ask you even to give up your music and try to work with us, though
I think you might have done that. I only ask you to use some psalms and
tunes which are fit to be used in a church.”

“To be sure us ool. ‘Taint we as wants no new-fangled tunes; them as we
sings be aal owld ones as ha’ been used in our church ever since I can
mind. But you only choose thaay as you likes out o’ the book? and we be
ready to kep to thaay.”

“I think Mr. Walker made a selection for you some weeks ago,” said Miss
Winter; “did he not?”

“‘Ees, but ’tis narra mossel o’ use for we to try his ‘goriums and sich
like. I hopes you wun’t be offended wi’ me, miss, for I be telling
nought but truth.” He spoke louder as they got nearer to the school
door, and, as they were opening it, shouted his last shot after them,
“‘Tis na good to try thaay tunes o’ his’n, miss. When us praises God, us
likes to praise un joyful.”

“There, you hear that, Mary,” said Miss Winter. “You’ll soon begin to
see why I look grave. There never was such a hard parish to
manage. Nobody will do what they ought. I never can get them to do
anything. Perhaps we may manage to teach the children better, that’s my
only comfort.”

“But, Katie dear, what do the poor things sing? Psalms, I hope.”

“Oh yes, but they choose all the odd ones on purpose, I believe. Which
class will you take?”

The little choir of children sang admirably, led by the schoolmistress,
and Miss Winter and the curate exchanged approving glances. They
performed the liveliest chant in their collection, that the opposition
might have no cause to complain of their want of joyfulness. And in turn
Miss Winter was in hopes that, out of deference to her, the usual rule
of selection in the gallery might have been modified. It was with no
small annoyance, therefore, that, after the Litany was over, and the
tuning finished, she heard the clerk give out that they would praise God
by singing part of the ninety-first Psalm. Mary, who was on the tiptoe
of expectation as to what was coming, saw the curate give a slight shrug
with his shoulders and lift of his eyebrows as he left the reading-desk,
and in another minute it became a painful effort for her to keep from
laughing as she slyly watched her cousin’s face; while the gallery sang
with vigour worthy of any cause or occasion–

“On the old lion He shall go, The adder fell and long; On the young lion
tread also, With dragons stout and strong.”

The trebles took up the last line, and repeated–

“With dragons stout and strong;”

and then the whole strength of the gallery chorused again–

“With dra-gons stout and strong;”

and the bass-viol seemed to her to prolong the notes and to gloat over
them as he droned them out, looking triumphantly at the distant
curate. Mary was thankful to kneel down to compose her face. The first
trial was the severe one, and she got through the second psalm much
better; and by the time Mr. Walker had plunged fairly into his sermon
she was a model of propriety and sedateness again.

Why not to use AOL

I’m sure everyone who runs a mail server already knows this,
but clearly all the thousands or millions of people who use AOL,
including a number of my personal friends, do not.

This is addressing only the problem of the AOL mail delivery
service. I know there have been other problems with AOL in the
past; I don’t know or especially care about the current status of
those problems.

I also know that the people who are using AOL are doing it because
they haven’t actually done any research about the alternatives. So
while I don’t know anything about the price of using
AOL versus the alternatives, I strongly suspect that they don’t
either, which suggests that AOL is probably using this ignorance
to get away with charging more than the alternatives.

The reason to not use AOL to deliver your mail is that they
have an official corporate policy of not caring whether your mail
is delivered or not.

When they get one spam report about anyone in your
domain, they block all email the mentions that
domain.
If you think this sounds like something an
organization that wanted you to get mail from your friends would
do, you can stop reading now. I assure you, this policy includes,
and is often applied to, very large and famous and frequently
referenced domains like harvard.edu.

They currently have laymusic.org blocked. My
normal method for sending email uses this domain in the Sender, From,
Reply-to, and signature of my emails, so I have to do something
radically different from usual to not mention laymusic.org in my
emails.

It took
me a while to remember the magic for finding out where to report
this. If you try going to postmaster.aol.com, you have
to be a better documentation reader than I am (I used to make lots
of money being a good documentation reader)
to figure out what
to do from what they tell you there.

If you run your own webserver, the mail log gets the bounce
response from AOL which includes a URL to go to to fill out a form
asking them to stop bouncing your mail.

I used to run my own, but when I finally decided not to depend
on Verizon being able to fix anything for my internet access, I
had to give up my static IP address, which means that while I can
get dynamic dns and refer to my address by name instead of number, I can’t get what’s called reverse
dns (being able to go from the address to the name), which means lots of places (even ones that really want their
customers to get their mail) will bounce my mail if I use a server
on my machine, so I’m using the comcast server. Comcast doesn’t
pass on the bounce information from their logs in the bounce
message.

So the trick to find out where to go to tell AOL to debounce
your domain is to send a mail from gmail, which will put the
information from the log into the bounce message they send you.
Then you go to that URL and fill out your form. I did this last
Fall, and my domain was unbounced in a small number of days.

This Spring, this hasn’t happened yet. They asked me to fill
out a customer satisfaction survey this morning, and this is what
I wrote:

I reported that email from or referring to my domain was bouncing on May 21.

I was told that the problem had been resolved and mail would stop bouncing in “24 business hours” from then on May 27.

The mail is still bouncing on June 3.

I think your policy of bouncing all mail that mentions a given domain name based on one spam complaint about that domain is not the policy of an organization that wants to deliver the mail.

Your performance on resolving such a block is not the performance of
an organization that wants to resolve problems.

Then when I submitted the form I wrote that on, they said they
couldn’t count my survey because they didn’t think my verification
number (which I’d gotten in the mail this morning) was valid.

Even if you think AOL is the best way to get internet access,
you should still have some other way to get email. gmail,
hotmail, and yahoo will all give you an account for free, and many
organizations and universities will give you an account if you’re
a member or an alumnus/a. Even if you currently have a good isp,
you should still have a mail address that doesn’t depend on its
name, because it’s likely to change its name or go out of business
or become a not-so-good isp for you, and you’ll have to change
your email if that happens.

Netflix Watch Now

I put a fair amount of effort after getting my new TV into
having a computer that could use it as a monitor.

I expected to run MythTV on it. I did in
fact once have MythTV set up to record off-the-air shows for
playing later, but I reinstalled because something else wasn’t
working right, and really haven’t felt the
need to set it up again.

You do get better results from mythtv than you do from
hulu.com, but hulu.com is a lot less trouble, and seems to get
most of the things I want to watch on over-the-air TV.

At the moment, I’m also paying for Comcast digital TV with HD,
which is necessary if you want to watch baseball games or tennis
matches or some of the political debates, but is disappointing as a way to watch movies or tv
shows. You can find things if you work hard enough, but there
isn’t the variety of TV reruns and old movies that you would want.

But if you have a Windows computer hooked up to your TV, and a
Netflix account only a
couple of dollars a month more expensive than the cheapest, and
a fast broadband connection, you
can watch an increasing number of things with the click of the
button.

I had been using it only intermittently until last week, but
last week Comcast sent me a postcard claiming they’d doubled my
connection speed, and suddenly, watching online seems about the
same quality as watching DVD’s.

I’d always assumed that when there was enough stuff available
and the quality was good enough you’d want to watch some movies
that way on the nights you wanted a movie and didn’t have a
DVD. This saves you paying for more DVD’s at a time than you’re
generally going to watch.

But it turns out that what it’s really good for is when you
come home tired and want to watch a comedy for a bit before
going to bed. I’ve been watching the first season of 30 Rock, which I didn’t get hooked on at the
time. It’s really a lot easier than channel surfing on the
cable box (which is unnecessarily complicated), and you get
something you know you’re in the mood for.

It would probably be even more virtuous to not use TV to unwind
at the end of the day, but given that’s what I’m used to doing,
and given I’ve spent all the money anyway, this seems like the
way to do it.

I don’t recommend spending lots of money just to get this, but
if like me you’re paying for a fast internet connection for
other reasons, it might be worth paying netflix and setting up
an old computer so you can do this.

Using a different browser

Until the recent urge to upgrade my computing
environment
, I was using firefox as my
main browser. This was not because it’s a particularly good
program, but because it has managed to get enough market share
away from Internet Explorer that the people who design
websites test on it. There are very few websites, except for
the ones that deliberately try to restrict themselves to
commercial OS’s, that don’t work on Firefox for Linux.

Unfortunately, there are at least two major problems with
Firefox on Linux, that cause me to try other things from time
to time:

  • It has major memory leaks. This means that if you keep your
    system running for weeks, or even days, at a time, after a while
    Firefox will grab enough of the memory that everything,
    including the program that draws the windows on the screen, is
    gasping for memory, and going to read the hard drive before
    drawing every pixel. I knew that killing firefox would fix
    this, but I kept not getting around to it until killing firefox
    took several minutes, because of waiting for the pixels to
    redraw.
  • Less common of a problem for me, but still a sign of an
    uncivilized program, is that once you play music with firefox,
    it grabs some sound resource, and doesn’t let it go, so the next
    time you want to run some of the other music programs I use, you
    have to kill firefox to do it. (For those who wonder, the way
    to do this is the command “alsa force-reload”. This kills all
    the programs that are holding onto resources that prevent alsa
    from reloading the modules it uses.)

Now some people claim that opera is a good
browser for their purposes. Whenever I download it and try it,
it takes me about 10 minutes before I find a site that doesn’t
work with it. I believe the site I do my online banking at is a
frequent offender, so if you have a bank that tests their online
banking with opera, maybe you don’t have my problems. But
switching banks is even harder than switching browsers, and by
most of the bank evaluation criteria I use, mine is pretty good, so
I’m not going to drop them just because their software testing
leaves something to be desired.

A lot of the other browsers for Linux are in fact using the
mozilla engine, which is the same one Firefox uses. Of course,
I don’t know exactly where in the code these memory leaks and
resource hoardings happen, but it wouldn’t surprise me if a
different browser using the same engine had the same
problems.

However, it is possible to install an alpha test version of
google’s chromium-browser for Linux. The version for windows
has been out for a few months and gotten rave reviews for being
clean and fast. The Linux version has a lot of things
that don’t work, but for the ones that do, it’s really a lot of
fun to use.

It’s a nuisance to be doing testing on alpha
software (which was pre-alpha until a few days ago). And of course I
need to restart chromium-browser every day when I get the new copy.
And do some testing to find out which things work today.
Yesterday was very exciting, because “copy link address” worked
for the first time. But today, it doesn’t seem to want to
display some slightly complicated PHP for my wordpress
administration, which it’s been doing for some time. Another
button that’s inconsistent is the “Publish” button when I
publish a new post. And of course, they aren’t even claiming
that printing or flash work. I also still haven’t reconfigured
emacs to use chromium instead of firefox, so when I click on a
URL in my email, I still get a tab in Firefox.

So I do still have to keep a copy of Firefox running, but it
usually only has one or two tabs on it, so it isn’t that much of
a nuisance if I have to restart it, and it actually behaves very
much like a civilized program if you’re closing most tabs right
after you open them.